Back to blog
Pricing

Best Shopify subscription apps compared on price

Selling subscriptions on Shopify takes an app, and those apps charge in very different ways. The price lists side by side, a worked example per size and what a European shop needs on top: iDEAL and SEPA direct debit.

15 October 202610 min read

What does a Shopify subscription app do?

A subscription app lets a customer order a product once and then receive it on a fixed rhythm, paying automatically each time. If you want to sell Shopify subscriptions, you need such an app: it puts the subscription plans on your products, turns every delivery into an order in Shopify and takes care of the payment.

Almost every Shopify subscription app does the same five things. The differences are in the price, the payment methods and what else is in the app. That is what the rest of this comparison is about.

  • Plans on the product (selling plans): a frequency such as every 2, 4 or 8 weeks, with or without a discount.
  • The choice on the product page: buy once or subscribe.
  • Recurring orders: on the billing date a new order appears in Shopify and the amount is charged.
  • A customer portal: the customer skips a delivery, pauses or cancels without having to email you.
  • Handling failed payments: the app tries again and asks the customer to update the payment or payment method.

Shopify's own app

Shopify also has its own subscription app: Shopify Subscriptions. According to the Shopify Help Center it offers:

  • weekly, monthly or yearly subscriptions that are billed automatically;
  • several plans, with discounts;
  • skipping, pausing and cancelling;
  • a widget on the product page;
  • notification emails;
  • customers manage their subscriptions from their customer accounts.

If that covers what you need and your customers pay with a method Shopify supports for subscriptions, look at Shopify's own app first before choosing another one. Its price is not in the tables below; check it in the Shopify App Store.

iDEAL and SEPA for Shopify subscriptions

For a Dutch or European shop this is often the first question. According to the Shopify Help Center (read on 15 October 2026) subscriptions are charged through Shopify Payments, PayPal Express, Authorize.net, Adyen and Stripe, with Stripe only available to select merchants. The Help Center adds that local, manual or non-credit-card payment methods might not be available for subscriptions.

As a rule, then, you cannot have a Shopify subscription paid again and again with iDEAL. iDEAL is a one-off payment: the customer confirms every amount at their bank. To charge the next delivery without the customer doing anything, you need a standing mandate: SEPA direct debit.

Loyalo solves this with your own Mollie account. The customer pays the first order with iDEAL. From that payment Loyalo creates a SEPA mandate in your Mollie account, and the following deliveries are collected by direct debit. When a debit fails, Loyalo tries again on the days you set (by default after 1, 3 and 5 days) and the customer gets an email with a payment link. One-time purchases and subscriptions by card simply go through your Shopify checkout.

Loyalo is not the only app that lists iDEAL and SEPA. Firmhouse lists iDEAL, SEPA and Bancontact. If you need Bancontact, that is a reason to look at Firmhouse.

Shopify subscription apps: the price lists

Below are the plans as each app publishes them, read on 4 October 2026. These are list prices: annual discounts, deals and extra modules are not included. Prices may have changed since, so check the current price with the app itself.

AppPlans (price per month, up to)Source
Recharge25 to 50 subscribers: $ 25 (up to 50 subscriptions); Starter: $ 99 + 1.49% + $ 0.19 per order (no limit stated); Plus: $ 499 + 1.34% + $ 0.19 per order (no limit stated)Shopify App Store
JuoStandard: $ 199 + 1.25% + $ 0.19 per order (no limit stated); Pro: $ 499 + 1% + $ 0.10 per order (no limit stated)Shopify App Store
Loop SubscriptionsFree: $ 0 (up to 50 subscriptions); Starter: $ 99 + 1% (no limit stated); Pro: $ 399 + 0.75% (no limit stated)Shopify App Store
FirmhouseBase: € 125 + 1.25% (no limit stated); Advanced: € 399 + 1% (no limit stated)firmhouse.com/pricing
Appstle SubscriptionsFree: $ 0 (up to $ 500 subscription revenue per month); Starter: $ 10 (up to $ 5,000 subscription revenue per month); Business: $ 30 (up to $ 15,000 subscription revenue per month); Business Premium: $ 100 (up to $ 100,000 subscription revenue per month)Shopify App Store
Seal SubscriptionsFree: $ 0 (up to 50 subscriptions); Supersale: $ 5.95 (up to 100 subscriptions); Rising Star: $ 9.95 (up to 250 subscriptions); Legend: $ 24.95 (up to 500 subscriptions)Shopify App Store
LoyaloGrowth: € 99 (up to 250 subscriptions); Scale: € 299 (no limit stated)loyalo.ai/pricing

Two things come on top at Loyalo that are not in the table. Customer Loyalty (points, tiers and rewards) is an add-on on top of a plan: € 99 per month (€ 1,089 a year) with Growth, € 199 per month (€ 2,189 a year) with Scale and Scale B2B. Standing orders for business customers are in the Scale B2B plan for € 499 per month. Loyalo charges nothing per order, and you can try everything free for 14 days.

Worked example: 100, 500 and 2,000 subscriptions

What an app costs depends on your size. This worked example assumes € 30 per delivery and one delivery per month. For each app it shows the cheapest plan from its price list that the shop fits in. Dollars are converted at the ECB rate of 2 October 2026: 1.1225 dollars per euro. Your payment provider's fees come on top with every app.

App100 subscriptions500 subscriptions2,000 subscriptions
Recharge$ 168 (€150), Starter$ 445 (€396), Starter$ 1,483 (€1,321), Starter
Juo$ 260 (€232), Standard$ 504 (€449), Standard$ 1,373 (€1,223), Pro
Loop Subscriptions$ 133 (€118), Starter$ 267 (€238), Starter$ 773 (€688), Starter
Firmhouse€163, Base€313, Base€875, Base
Appstle Subscriptions$ 10 (€9), Starter$ 100 (€89), Business Premium$ 100 (€89), Business Premium
Seal Subscriptions$ 6 (€5), Supersale$ 25 (€22), Legendprice on request
Loyalo€99, Growth€299, Scale€299, Scale

What comes out below Loyalo in this example:

  • 100 subscriptions: Appstle Subscriptions and Seal Subscriptions come out below Loyalo (€99).
  • 500 subscriptions: Loop Subscriptions, Appstle Subscriptions and Seal Subscriptions come out below Loyalo (€299).
  • 2,000 subscriptions: Appstle Subscriptions comes out below Loyalo (€299).

The conclusion: Seal and Appstle are cheaper than Loyalo at almost every size. Loop is free up to 50 active subscriptions and Recharge costs $ 25 up to 50 subscribers; at those small numbers they are cheaper or free. Where an app charges a percentage of revenue, the difference grows with your size.

Do the maths with your own numbers

Fill in your own number of subscriptions and amount per delivery. With a higher amount per delivery, percentages weigh more; if your shop delivers more than once a month, amounts per order count more often. The comparison page for each app has a calculator.

Fixed price or percentage of revenue

The apps charge in three ways. Recharge, Juo, Loop and Firmhouse charge a fixed amount plus a percentage of your subscription revenue in their paid plans, and Recharge and Juo add an amount per order. Appstle charges a fixed amount per band of subscription revenue. Seal and Loyalo charge a fixed amount per band of the number of subscriptions.

With a percentage you pay little while you are small, but every extra delivery costs something. With a fixed amount you know in advance what you pay, even as your revenue grows. So work out what you pay now and what you would pay at the size you expect in a year.

Which subscription app fits which shop

No Shopify subscription app is the best choice for every shop. Go through these points and cross off what you do not need.

  • Pricing model: do you want a fixed amount per month, or is a percentage of revenue cheaper for you?
  • Payment: do your customers pay with iDEAL, and do you want to collect the following deliveries by SEPA direct debit?
  • Language: which language do you use in the dashboard, and in which languages do your customers read the product page choice, the portal and the emails?
  • Loyalty: do you want points and tiers in the same app as your subscriptions, or do you use a separate app for that?
  • Business customers: do you need standing orders on account for B2B?
  • Switching: do you already have subscribers in another app, and can you bring them over without them ordering again?

Another app fits better if one of these weighs heavily for you:

  • You want the lowest price and do not need iDEAL with direct debit, points with tiers or B2B: Seal or Appstle.
  • You have at most 50 subscriptions: Loop is then free, Recharge then costs $ 25 per month.
  • You want what Recharge lists in its Plus plan, such as SMS management for subscribers, a JavaScript SDK and hands-on implementation.
  • You want what Juo lists in its Pro plan, such as curated boxes, SMS notifications and white-glove onboarding.
  • You want what Loop lists in its Pro plan, such as a dedicated customer success manager, Slack support and gamified subscriber journeys.
  • You sell rental, lease or try & buy, or you need Bancontact: Firmhouse lists those.

Loyalo fits better if you want a fixed amount per month without a percentage and without an amount per order, if your customers pay with iDEAL and the following deliveries are collected through your own Mollie account, or if you want subscriptions, a points program with tiers and standing orders for business customers in one app. The dashboard is in Dutch and English, with support in Dutch. What your customers read, such as the product page choice, the portal and the emails, follows your shop's language.

For every app in the table there is a separate comparison page with Loyalo on this site: the price list, three worked examples and when which app fits better.

Switching to another subscription app

If you choose another app while subscriptions are running, your subscribers do not have to order again. You can move over from any app that gives a CSV export of the subscriptions, such as Juo, Recharge and Appstle. The order matters more than the data: two apps that both charge give double charges.

  1. Copy the plansLoyalo finds the plans of your old app on your products and turns them into plans of its own, with the same frequencies and discounts.
  2. Import the subscriptionsUpload the CSV export. Loyalo recognises the common column names, checks every row and shows what will be created. Nothing happens until you click import, and the import sends no emails.
  3. Stop the old appStop the charges in the old app before the next billing date, without it sending customers a cancellation email.
  4. Switch on chargingSwitch on charging in Loyalo. From then on every delivery runs through Loyalo.

A payment method comes along when it is stored in Shopify or as an iDEAL mandate in your own Mollie account. If it is stored with another party, the customer gives a new mandate once with a payment of € 0.01 through iDEAL.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best subscription app for Shopify?

That depends on your shop. If you want the lowest price and your customers pay by card, Seal and Appstle are the cheapest at almost every size according to their price lists. If your customers pay with iDEAL, or you want loyalty and B2B in the same app, other things weigh more than price alone.

How much does a Shopify subscription app cost?

According to the price lists in the table, from free to a few hundred dollars or euros per month, with some apps adding a percentage of your subscription revenue. What you really pay depends on your number of subscriptions and your revenue. Do the maths with your own numbers.

Does Shopify have its own subscription app?

Yes, Shopify Subscriptions. According to the Shopify Help Center it lets you sell weekly, monthly or yearly subscriptions with discounts, and customers can skip, pause and cancel from their customer accounts.

Can Shopify subscriptions be paid with iDEAL?

Not with Shopify itself: according to the Shopify Help Center, local payment methods might not be available for subscriptions. With Loyalo the customer pays the first time with iDEAL and the following deliveries are collected by SEPA direct debit through your own Mollie account.

Is a fixed price or a percentage cheaper?

With small subscription revenue a percentage is often cheaper, because you pay little while you sell little. As your revenue grows, a percentage grows with it and a fixed amount does not. Where the turning point lies, you work out with your own number of subscriptions and amount per delivery.

Is Loyalo the cheapest subscription app?

No. Seal and Appstle are cheaper at almost every size, and Loop and Recharge are cheaper or free at very small numbers. Loyalo costs € 99 per month up to 250 active subscriptions and € 299 above that, without a percentage and without an amount per order.

Can I switch subscription apps later?

Yes, if your old app gives a CSV export of the subscriptions. You import the running subscriptions into the new app; a payment method stored in Shopify comes along, so customers do not have to order again.

Can I have subscriptions and a points program in one app?

In Loyalo, yes: Customer Loyalty with points, tiers and rewards is an add-on on top of a plan, € 99 per month with Growth and € 199 with Scale. Whether other apps offer this too, check their own descriptions.

What Loyalo costs, per plan

The pricing page shows what each Loyalo plan costs and what is in it. You can try everything free for 14 days.

To pricing

Start selling subscriptions in Shopify

Try Loyalo free for 14 days with every feature. After that you pay a fixed monthly price, with no per-order fee.