Retention

Reduce churn on Shopify subscriptions

A customer who cancels often wants something different: fewer deliveries, a later date or a lower price. Loyalo offers that alternative the moment a customer wants to stop, recovers failed payments and gives former subscribers a reason to come back.

4
kinds of offer when cancelling
Up to 6
new attempts after a failed payment
1 click
skip or reschedule from the email
€ 0
extra: retention is in every plan
Voluntary churn

An offer that fits the cancellation reason

Someone with too much at home is better served by a pause than a discount. Someone who finds it too expensive wants a lower price. So Loyalo asks for the reason first and then makes one offer.

In the portal

First the reason, then the alternative

The customer chooses why they want to stop and immediately sees an alternative that fits that reason. One button accepts the offer, the other cancels anyway.

  • The customer gets the offer once, before the subscription stops
  • Cancelling stays one click away: a subscription taken out online must be easy to cancel online
  • Loyalo keeps the reason, so you can see why customers stop
Cancelling in the customer portal: the customer picks a reason and gets the offer to skip the next delivery
In your dashboard

You choose the offer per reason

You set up to ten reasons and choose what the customer is offered for each one. Below the settings you see the results of the last 90 days.

  • A discount on a number of upcoming deliveries you choose
  • Skipping the next delivery
  • Pausing for 1 to 6 months
  • Delivering less often, with the same discount
  • A waiting period, so 'cancel' does not become a discount button
Settings in Loyalo for cancelling: the reasons, the offer per reason, the default discount and the result of the last ninety days

How a cancellation goes

  1. 01

    The customer clicks cancel

    In the customer portal, without calling or emailing. If you set a minimum term or notice period, the customer sees when the subscription ends.

  2. 02

    They pick a reason

    From your list, for example 'too expensive', 'still have plenty' or 'delivery does not suit me'.

  3. 03

    They get one offer

    The offer that belongs to that reason. When they accept, the subscription continues with the discount, the pause or the new rhythm.

  4. 04

    You see why

    Analytics shows which reasons customers give and how many stayed after an offer.

Involuntary churn

Dunning: recovering failed payments

Some subscribers stop without meaning to: the card expired or the balance was just too low. A retry schedule and a timely email to the customer solve most of these cases.

Retries

New attempts on the days you choose

When a collection fails, Loyalo tries again, by default after 1, 3 and 5 days. The customer gets an email after every failed attempt. You choose what happens when all attempts fail.

  • Up to six attempts, on days you enter yourself
  • An attempt in the four days before payday moves to the morning after
  • For iDEAL, a payment link that renews the mandate at once
  • After that: pause, cancel or leave it running
  • An email when the card expires before the next delivery
Settings for collecting in Loyalo: new attempts after 1, 3 and 5 days, payday, what happens when everything fails and when a product is out of stock
Win-back

A reason to come back

A set number of days after cancelling, the customer gets a personal discount code that only they can use, once. Loyalo sends it once per subscription, and not if the customer still has another subscription. In the portal a stopped subscription stays visible for twelve months, with a Restart button.

  • You choose after how many days, how much discount and how long the code is valid
  • With Klaviyo you get the event 'Winback Offer' for your own flow
  • You see how many codes were sent and how many customers came back
Settings for win-back in Loyalo: customers who stopped get a personal discount code after a number of days
Before the cancellation

A reason to stay

A subscription that adapts to the customer is cancelled less often.

One-time extras

Something extra with the next delivery

Subscribers add a single product to their next delivery, in the portal or through the link in the reminder email. You can give it a subscriber discount. The extra is charged with that delivery and then drops off the subscription.

  • You choose the products, the discount and the maximum per delivery
  • Paid by card or through the iDEAL mandate
  • You see how many extras are waiting and what they brought in
Settings for one-time extras in Loyalo: the products, the discount for subscribers and the maximum per delivery

Flexible subscriptions last longer

Pause instead of stop

The customer pauses, resumes and moves the delivery date in the portal, without emailing you and without ordering again.

Read more

One click from the email

The reminder for the next delivery has buttons to skip or reschedule right away. The customer does not need to log in for that.

Swapping products

Customers choose another flavour or size within the same plan and keep the discount. Wanting a change no longer has to mean cancelling.

Earning on every delivery

With the Customer Loyalty add-on every delivery earns points, and a higher tier gives a discount or free shipping.

Read more
Measuring

Check that your retention works

Analytics shows these figures for the period you choose, such as the last 30 or 90 days, a quarter or your own dates, always next to the period before.

Check that your retention works
FigureWhat it tells you
ChurnThe share of subscriptions cancelled in the period, divided by what was running at the start
Cancellation reasonsWhich reasons customers choose most often
Offer acceptedThe share of customers who stayed after an offer
Paid after allThe share of deliveries that were paid after a failed attempt
With a payment problem nowHow many subscriptions are waiting for a new attempt right now
CohortsWhich share of the subscriptions from a start month is still running after a number of months
Following up

Nothing slips through

A schedule only works when you can see what it does. Subscriptions with a payment problem rise to the top by themselves.

See what you can measure
  • Subscriptions with a failed payment are at the top of the list, with the date of the next attempt
  • 'Retry now' collects once more right away
  • Log › Status shows tasks that went wrong, with the error and a button to retry
  • Every change and every attempt is in the history of the subscription

Frequently asked questions about churn and retention

What is churn for subscriptions?

Churn is the share of subscribers who stop in a period. Loyalo calculates it as the number of stopped subscriptions divided by the number of running subscriptions at the start of the period. Voluntary churn is a customer who cancels; involuntary churn is a subscription that stops because a payment fails.

What is dunning?

Dunning is the follow-up of failed payments: retrying the payment and telling the customer something went wrong. In Loyalo you set the days of the new attempts, the customer gets an email with every attempt and you choose what happens when everything fails.

Can I make a different offer per cancellation reason?

Yes. For every reason you choose a discount, skipping a delivery, pausing, delivering less often or no offer. A reason without its own offer gets the default discount you set.

Does a customer get a discount every time they click 'cancel'?

No. The same subscription only gets a new offer after a waiting period. The default is 180 days, and you can change it.

How often does Loyalo retry a payment?

As often as you set, up to six times. By default three times: after 1, 3 and 5 days. An attempt in the four days before payday moves to the morning after automatically; you can switch that off.

What is a win-back?

An email with a personal discount code for a customer who stopped, a number of days after cancelling that you set. Loyalo sends it, or you build your own flow in Klaviyo on the Winback Offer event.

Can I set a minimum term or a notice period?

Yes. You set a minimum number of deliveries and a notice period of at most a month. When a customer cancels earlier, the subscription stops after the term or the notice period and they get a confirmation of that.

What happens when a product is out of stock on the collection day?

You choose: collect anyway, wait a few days for stock to return (and skip if it does not), or skip the delivery straight away. When a delivery is skipped, the customer gets an email.

Does retention cost extra?

No. The cancellation flow with offers, retries for failed payments, the win-back and one-time extras are in every plan.

Read on: Setting up retention and dunningBlog: reducing churnBlog: dunning for failed payments

Demo

Request a demo or a trial

In half an hour we show you how Loyalo works in your store, or we send you an install link right away. The trial runs for 14 days and needs no credit card.

See where your subscribers drop off

In a demo we walk through the cancellation flow, the retries and the figures behind them.